The other end of the Jurying Process

My painting, "Lydia's First Day", awarded "Best of Show" by Bill Hosner at 2006 PSSW show
Today I spent many hours looking at hundreds of entries to the 116th Juried open Exhibition of the Catharine Lorillard Wolfe Art Club. The CLWAC was established in 1896 and the show will be held at the National Arts Club in NYC in October. Needless to say, I was extremely honored when they asked me to be one of the jurors of selection. Having entered this show several times in the past myself as well as many, many other juried exhibitions, I learned a lot experiencing the jury process from the other side and I would like to share some of my thoughts.
Here is how the process worked: I was sent a CD with all of the entries, images only (except in some cases, more on that later). There were also six pages with the following information: artwork title, number of work corresponding to the image number, medium, size and a column for me to mark "yes" or "no". There are several jurors and the paintings getting the most "yes" votes from all of the jurors get accepted into the show. Another juror then awards the prizes.
My first step was to open the CD and see all of the images in thumbnail form. I immediately was able to spot the ones with great design and values. Even from such a small image I made marks on my sheet of paper next to the ones that stood out.
I then opened each image separately to view it large and by itself. Here is what surprised me: some images which had read very well as thumbnails did not hold up well when viewed larger. While the overall shapes, colors and values may have been good, some pieces revealed an unsure hand, hesitant brushstrokes which made it appear amateurish and showed a lack of confidence.
On the other hand, some images which did not stand out as a thumbnail looked much better when viewed larger. However, this is an exception. Your paintings should always read well as a thumbnail, so be sure to check it out that way before sending it off to a juried competition or even before sending it out of your studio at all. If it doesn't read well small it will not read well from across the room at a
gallery or in someone's home!
I was also very surprised and dismayed at how many artists still send in images that are not photographed well. Entering competitions costs money, so why skimp and send in bad photos of your work risking immediate elimination? By bad I mean photos that are not in focus, have bad lighting (too much sheen, too dark) or show more than the actual painting. The latter I thought was a no-brainer since most show instructions are adamant about this. Do NOT ever include the matting or framing, let alone your easel or clips.
Also, DO shoot the photo straight on, not at an angle.
And, do NOT include your full name, title, medium, phone number (yes, this was done!) on the same image as your artwork! There is a separate area for this for a reason. The artist is supposed to be anonymous to the juror (although I admit that I recognized some well known artists' work even without seeing their name). Including anything other than the art takes away from your painting and does not look professional.
Some tips: if you photograph your work yourself (which I do most of the time) do so outdoors on a sunny day in the shade. Up until recently I had a covered patio which worked great for this. I put a nail in the wall so I could hang my painting flat against it. Use a tripod for your camera. Shoot in both 72 and 300 dpi (but this can also be changed on your computer later). Learn how your camera works or spend the money to have a professional who specializes in photographing artwork do it for you. If you are serious about your art, you need to invest the time or money to produce good images of your work.
Crop out anything that is not part of your painting on your computer. If you do not know how, ask a friend to help you (your teenage kids are also great at this) or, as my Significant Other loves to say:"Google it!" There really is NO excuse to not knowing how to crop an image. Don't enter competitions until you know how to do this. Many will eliminate your piece because of this, no matter how good the art!
The criteria by which I was to choose the accepted entries was that the work meets the quality, talent and professionalism of the CLWAC.
As a member and a juror I took this very seriosuly. I did not want to be responsible for putting together an exhibition that was anything less than what the CLWAC stands for. I felt my reputation as a juror was at stake and seeing unprofessional photos and or/art told me the artist was just not experienced enough to be part of this prestigious group.
Some pieces were very hard to judge how they would look in person. Was the painting really this dark or was it due to a bad photo? Are the colors really this washed out or would they be brighter in reality? Since there was no way to know for sure I would have to reject it.
On very rare occasions did I take a chance and marked "yes" on a painting that I trusted would hold up well at the exhibition even though the photo was subpar.
For the most part, I found it very easy to spot the winners right off the bat. The ones that packed a punch, first by their composition and design, colors and values (whether realistic or abstract), and then touched an emotional chord (no matter the subject matter). There were pieces that sang with color and clearly showed the hand and heart of the artist, paintings that made me smile and paintings that made me think.
At times, it was hard rejecting a piece, knowing how much it will sting, but some were just not ready for prime time yet, and a showing at the National Arts Club IS prime time! I wish I could have written to some of the artists, telling them not to give up, to keep going because they are on the right track.
Other times, the rejections came easily, mainly for lack of a strong design, focal point, or technical skill. Skill level, to me, is not a complete deal breaker however. I voted "yes" on a piece or two that were created by artists who still had a little ways to go as far as drawing or painting skills, but if I saw a clear vision, a story that sparked my interest, a passion in the subject matter, it got a positive response from me. I remember Bill Hosner awarding me a "Best of Show" at a Pastel Society of the Southwest exhibit a few years ago and telling me that there were some drawing inaccuracies, but that my painting evoked such an emotional response from him that he felt it deserved the top award. I have not forgotten that and now I completely understand what he meant.
After I viewed each piece in a large format, I went back to the thumbnails and reviewed them all. There were quite a few on which I was undecided, but viewing them as thumbnails again made the decision clear as day immediately. Again: I recommend that you always view your paintings in a reduced size before calling it finished (another good idea is to view them in grayscale to check for strong values and design).
I am eager to find out how many of my choices were also the choices of the other judges and made it into the show. I have a feeling I know which ones will be the top award winners, but I may be surpirsed by a few, too!
It was enlightening to see how it feels as a juror to view hundreds of paintings at a time and I am coming away from the experience knowing what to look for in my own submissions in the future.
To close, I'd like to share my own philosophy when we are on the receiving end of a rejection letter: It was simply someone else's turn to get accepted or win an award. There will be another time for you.
Comments
8 Responses to The other end of the Jurying Process
Leave a Comment